Your honor, while the defense makes several good points about the defendant’s strengths, it makes no mention of the game’s obvious faults. The biggest problem with Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney is that it has very limited replay value. While the game is surprisingly long for a text based adventure game, with four of the five cases each taking about 3-5 hours to complete, the fact is that the game has very little replay value. Once you have experienced the story, there is next to no reason to go back and play it again. No branching story lines, no additional endings, no unlockables, no nothing. While the game gives you choices on what you want to say, 95% of the time these choices have no impact on the outcome of the game. The remaining 5% comes from the fact that there are one or two choices where making the wrong choice will result in you either losing the case or losing an exclamation point.
This unique DS game packs humor, great characters, some amazing storytelling.
Additionally, the previously mentioned investigation gameplay segments can be very boring due to the fact that sometimes, the only way to progress is to find the one witness who is looking for this one piece of evidence that you may or may not have at the moment. The investigation segments are not nearly as interesting as the trial portions of the game and can cause gamers to try and get through them as fast as they can to try and get back to the fun of the game.
Finally, some might be turned off by the fact that it is not even close to an accurate representation of our legal system. In the game, defendants are guilty until proven innocent, witnesses can change their testimonies after being clearly caught lying, lawyers can object as much as they want to whatever they want, the judge has the mental capacity of a five year old at times, and a person can be convicted of murder just because a witness says that he saw him do it.
The Verdict
Taking both sides into consideration, this court recognizes that Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney is a very unique game on a handheld system that needs these kinds of innovative titles to set itself apart from its more powerful competition. Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney packs humor, great characters, some amazing storytelling, and engaging gameplay that is only marred by a few boring moments and a lack of replay value. It resurrects a beloved genre that has stagnated ever since the old Lucasarts adventure games.
Review by Mitchell Saltzman.
Highs
Unique gaming experience that is actually a lot of fun; Lots of humor; Excellent music and sound effects; Superb storyline that has more twists and turns than a roller-coaster ride designed by a crazy thrill seeker; Lots of great humor; Actual game length is fairly long, but...
Lows
While the actual game is lengthy, there is no real reason to play it again; Investigation segments can be boring; The way the legal system is portrayed is almost insulting; Outdated graphics.
Final Verdict
On the charge of being an excellent adventure game on the DS, Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney is declared guilty as charged.
Not a member? Register here for free! It's quick and easy.